Actually This Thing Is Trash – Logitech X56 HOTAS Review Update
I don’t do this often, but this thing has me so mad that I have to do an updated review. A few weeks ago I reviewed this, my Logitech X56 HOTAS I bought open box like six months ago. I’ve used it a lot since then, but literally the day my review went live it’s like it knew, and decided then was the perfect day to start failing. So now I have some more complaints, and have already purchased a much, much better solution. If you want to know my less angry but potentially more balanced thoughts on the X56, check out the first video in the cards, but if you’ve already seen that, here’s the angry version.
Here’s the briefest of recaps on the X56 if you didn’t watch the first video. The X56 HOTAS is a decade old design originally made by Saitek (and Mad Catz), although the older X52 and X54 are even older and basically the same design. The stick is a hall effect stick at least, but it uses a single spring and cone for its centring force which is one of my chief complaints. You do get a whole lot of buttons here at least, including two mini analog sticks between them, although the flight stick is definitely on the large side, making for a less-than-comfortable experience overall. The throttles also only have two way momentary toggle switches – I’d love at least one of these sets to be latching – i.e they stay in their on/off position so you can see stuff like your gear is down by the switch position, y’know? Anyway that’s about all the good I have to say, so moving on…
Everything here is plastic. The stick is plastic, the throttles are plastic. The gear that adjusts the throttle force is plastic. Hell even the tiny pins that the mechanism inside the throttles rides on is plastic. How do I know this? Because the day my review went live the damn thing broke. And I tried fixing it too, but it broke again almost immediately. That’s impressive. So basically the way this works is inside the throttles is a kinda taco-lookin thing that the wheel on the side adjusts up or down depending on how much resistance you want, sliding more or less of the taco into the throttle handle’s innards. The taco rides on three pins – the middle of which is also the gear that raises and lowers it. Technically there’s also four very thin tracks that the taco rides in, but those three pins sheared off and the taco left the chat. I glued them back down, but almost immediately one broke again. Awesome. Oh, to clarify how this works, basically this is covered in a super sticky silicone lubricant, and the more the taco is inserted, the more surface area the sticky lube has to grab onto. This presents a really weird force profile though, as on slow, deliberate movement (think commercial aviation) this feels smooth and stiff, but with fast movement (think MilSim) it’s firm at first, then is practically free-moving. For the kinds of games I enjoy – I’ve been playing Project Wingman since posting the first video – this feels dreadful. Part of that might be because I can’t even raise the taco anymore due to those pins breaking, but still. That’s rough.
Another thing that ruins the experience – and something that legitimately only started failing the second I posted the last video (can you tell I’m mad I’ve been made a liar by an inanimate piece of plastic?) – is the soft touch coating. This started degrading super quickly, especially on the throttle as that has full palm contact, leaving my hands feeling sticky and gross. While I do have what Adam Savage calls “Piss Hands” (look it up, it’s not what you think, it’s funnier), this is insane. And I just hate soft-touch coatings. It’s a hallmark of a cheap design to me. For what was £250 for £2 worth of plastic, this feels cheap to me.
Oh and speaking of poor plastic, that’s the other thing. The flight stick is unreasonably weak and floppy. While my complaints about the spring and cone arrangement are still pretty top-of-the-grievance-list-worthy, and one thing I didn’t articulate well before is this design’s inability to have gentle, dead-centre movements that let you slightly adjust the craft, the stick’s main shaft is so slim and unreinforced that at the limits this will happily bend and feel like it’s just about to break off. Again, for what would have been £250 new this is rough. Sure, this is now £125 new which helps a lot, but man that’s a tough sell for MSRP.
These changes have definitely downgraded my opinion of this thing. This is entry level for a HOTAS, but even then I don’t know. I’m pretty sure there are, or frankly must be, better options out there. I’ve heard decent things about the Thrustmaster T.16000m, which for the same current price should be at least a little bit nicer. I’ve opted to splash out some more on a Virpil Cadet Aeromax and VMAX throttle – its all metal mechanism should be a lot more reliable – but there’s a backorder so I’m stuck with the X56 for a little while longer. I’ll absolutely give you my thoughts on the Virpil hardware once I get ‘em!
